Boundary wall, gate pillar, shed, tank base
Loads are light and simple. A BIS-licensed value bar does the job, and paying for Tata buys you little here.
Both are BIS-licensed TMT bars and both sit in our yard. Neither is fake or weak. They are built for different jobs.
If the drawing names a grade, buy that grade. Everything else on this page is for when it doesn't.
Every figure below is copied from the maker's own sheet, not from a dealer site or a list of "top 10 brands". Our Saluja Gold comes in on Birla Pivot's bills as Fe 500, so that is the column we compare.
| Tata Tiscon 550SD | Saluja Gold Fe 500 | |
|---|---|---|
| Strength | ||
| Grade | Fe 550D, "super ductile"6 mm in Tata's range is Tiscon 500D | Fe 500maker also rolls Fe 500D, Fe 550, Fe 550D, Fe 600 (SG600) |
| Yield strength, minimum | 570 MPa95% of test values; IS floor 550 | 520 MPaIS floor 500 |
| Tensile strength, minimum | 655 MPaand at least 15% above yield | 610 MPaIS asks 545 |
| Tensile ÷ yieldthe reserve after yielding | 1.15 to 1.25the band IS 13920 asks for | 1.17IS Fe 500 asks ≥ 1.08 |
| Stretch (ductility) | ||
| Elongation before breaking | 16%IS 550D asks 14.5 | 15%IS Fe 500 asks 12 |
| Stretch at peak load (Agt) | 5% | not givenFe 500 is not a "D" grade |
| Chemistry | ||
| Sulphur + phosphorus, max | 0.070% | 0.105% |
| Carbon, max | 0.25% | 0.28% |
| Buying | ||
| Weight tolerance, 12 mm | ± 3%± 5% up to 10 mm | − 5% / + 2%− 7% / + 3 to 4% up to 10 mm |
| How it is priced | By the 12 m piece, at Tata's Recommended Consumer Price, shown at dealers | By weight; the maker posts a Bihar price list. Bundles: 12 mm = 5 pieces, 16 mm = 3 |
| Proof it is genuine | "Tata Tiscon" and grade embossed on every bar; holographic "Tag of Trust" on every bundle | "SALUJA GOLD", size and ISI mark rolled on the bar; IS 1786 licence CM/L-5801867 |
| Made from | Iron ore → blast furnace → BOF steel, Tata's plants | Own sponge iron plus scrap → own billets → rolling mill, Giridih, Jharkhand |
| Extras | GreenPro certified ("India's first"); doorstep test lab, not offered in Bihar | ISO 9001 plant; selling in Bihar since 2014 |
| Sizes in our yard | 6, 8, 10, 12, 16 mm20 and 25 mm: we order them | 6, 8, 10, 12, 16 mm20 to 32 mm and other grades: we order them |
Pull a bar and it springs back, then gives and stretches, then breaks. The curve shows both bars from their makers' minimum figures.
Up to its yield load a bar springs back like a spring. Engineers design so everyday loads stay well below it. A higher yield lets a design use fewer kg, but only if the engineer designs for it. Swap a 550 bar into a 500 design and you just get extra margin.
Past yield, a good bar stretches a long way before it snaps. In an earthquake that stretching soaks up the shaking, and the cracks you see are a warning instead of a sudden collapse. Here the two bars are close: 16% against 15%.
A "D" grade (Fe 500D, 550D) is tested for stretch at peak load and has tighter limits on sulphur and phosphorus. Tata 550SD is a D bar. Our Saluja stock is Fe 500, not 500D. Its stretch is close to a D bar's, but it isn't sold or tested as one.
Muzaffarpur is in a high earthquake zone (zone IV under IS 1893). For a framed house here, engineers usually ask for a D grade. More on what Fe 500, 500D and 550D mean and sariya for Muzaffarpur's earthquake zone.
Tata is priced by the 12 m piece; Saluja is priced by weight. Our sariya rate page puts both in rupees per kg, so the gap is a fair comparison.
Put the extra next to the cost of the whole house. Steel is only one line of it, and the Tata-over-Saluja gap is a slice of that line. Whether that slice is worth it depends on the building, not on the brand: see the next section. Stage-by-stage kg: sariya calculator.
The question is not "which brand is better". It is "how hard will this building be tested, and will it grow?"
Loads are light and simple. A BIS-licensed value bar does the job, and paying for Tata buys you little here.
Fine with a certified bar laid to a sound plan: rings closed with 135° hooks, cover blocks, proper lap. Be honest with yourself about "never".
The columns and footings poured today must carry the floor you add in five years. Steel inside a cast slab can't be changed, so decide before dhalai.
Columns and beams carry everything, and the drawing often calls for earthquake detailing (IS 13920). That code asks for the 1.15 to 1.25 tensile-to-yield band that Tata's sheet promises.
He may well be right. A house shows nothing about its steel until it is tested. On ordinary days, a sound single-storey house uses only a small part of a certified bar's strength, and that can go on for decades. That is why the cheaper bar "looks fine".
The test comes on two days: the day you add a floor, and the day a strong earthquake comes. North Bihar has had big ones (1934 and 1988). On those days the bars in the columns get pushed past yield. Then what counts is how far they can stretch without snapping. That is where the "D" grade, low sulphur and phosphorus, and the 1.15 to 1.25 reserve earn their price.
Brand isn't the whole story, though. A Tata bar with open rings, no cover blocks and weak concrete will do worse than a Saluja bar laid properly. Spend on detailing first. Rings with 135° hooks, closer spacing near joints, a proper lap and good curing matter as much as the bar.
So the honest answer: if your house will stay single-storey and is simple, the cheaper certified bar is a fair choice. If it will grow, or an engineer has drawn a frame, the extra is a small slice of the house cost. Steel in a cast slab cannot be upgraded later.
Send photos of the bars and rings on WhatsApp before dhalai, and we will look at them with you.
The per-kg comparison only holds if each bar is full weight. Weigh one 12 m piece per size. Each maker publishes how light it may be.
| Size | Standard, 12 m piece | Saluja allows | Tata allows |
|---|---|---|---|
| 8 mm | 4.74 kg | 4.40–4.92 | 4.50–4.98 |
| 10 mm | 7.40 kg | 6.89–7.62 | 7.03–7.77 |
| 12 mm | 10.66 kg | 10.13–10.86 | 10.34–10.98 |
| 16 mm | 18.96 kg | 18.01–19.32 | 18.39–19.53 |
Standard weight per metre, labelled as such. Saluja figures from its leaflet; Tata figures worked out from its ± 5% (up to 10 mm) and ± 3% (12, 16 mm). More: sariya weight per metre.
Ask for the brand, grade and size on the bill. More checks: real or fake sariya.
Prices are from our latest bill and change often. Please confirm today's rate on WhatsApp or call before buying.
Tata Tiscon 550SD6, 8, 10, 12, 16 mm · 20, 25 mm we orderAsk today's rateper kgIt is a BIS-licensed TMT bar to IS 1786 (licence CM/L-5801867 on the maker's leaflet), made at Giridih, Jharkhand, from the company's own sponge iron and billets. For Fe 500, the grade we stock, the maker publishes a minimum yield of 520 MPa and 15% elongation, above the IS minimums of 500 and 12%. It suits boundary walls, sheds and single-storey houses that will stay single-storey.
Fe 500D is the IS 1786 grade with a 500 MPa minimum yield and 16% elongation (standard figure). Tata Tiscon 550SD is Tata's super-ductile Fe 550D bar: its sheet gives 570 MPa yield, 16% elongation, 5% stretch at peak load and a tensile-to-yield ratio of 1.15 to 1.25. Fuller answer: Fe 500, 500D and 550D.
For everyday loads he is probably right. What the costlier bar buys is margin for the day the house is tested: a strong earthquake, or a floor added later. If neither applies, the cheaper certified bar is fair. If either does, Tata's extra on a 1000 sq ft floor is about 3,500 to 4,000 times the per-kg gap. The full answer is above.
There is no single best. Buy the grade your engineer's drawing names. For a framed house, upper floors or earthquake detailing, choose a super-ductile bar such as Tata Tiscon 550SD. For a boundary wall, shed or simple single-storey house, a BIS-licensed value bar such as Saluja Gold is sensible.
Ask your engineer, and buy the grade on the drawing. Our stock is Fe 500. If the drawing asks for Fe 500D or 550D, we can order Saluja's D grades, or you can take Tata 550SD from stock. For a frame of G+1 and up in Muzaffarpur, we advise a D grade.
Use the method on this page: put the same rows side by side from each maker's own sheet for the same grade. Compare yield, tensile strength, elongation, sulphur plus phosphorus, weight tolerance and the BIS licence number. Don't trust a "top 10" list without figures. We keep Tata Tiscon and Saluja Gold in stock and can order other brands; ask on WhatsApp for the time it takes.
Not inside the same column, beam or slab. Keep one brand and grade per member so the engineer's design holds. Saluja for the boundary wall and Tata for the house frame is fine.
Tata sells 550SD by the 12 m piece at its Recommended Consumer Price. Saluja is priced by weight. To compare fairly, our sariya rate page shows both per kg, per quintal and per piece.
Handles cement and steel at our Reva Road store, Muzaffarpur, where both bars on this page are sold. Every figure here was copied from the maker's own sheet on 12 Nov 2026. Where a sheet is unclear or contradicts itself, this page says so.
Send your plan or drawing on WhatsApp. We'll tell you which bar, which sizes and how many kg, with today's price for both.